Ryan Romano and Julianne Huff

Why Willpower Isn’t Enough to Manage Emotions in Sports and the Power of Emotional Strength

In the world of sports, the concept of willpower is often heralded as the ultimate tool for success. Athletes are encouraged to push through pain, persevere through setbacks, and suppress negative emotions to stay focused on their goals. 

However, this approach not only fails to address the root of emotional experiences but also misunderstands the fundamental nature of emotions.

The Limitations of Willpower in Sports

Willpower is often likened to a muscle: it can be exercised and strengthened, but it also has limits and can become fatigued. 

When it comes to managing emotions, relying solely on willpower can be a misguided strategy for several reasons:

Emotional Fatigue: 

Just like physical muscles, the willpower muscle can get tired. 

Constantly using willpower to suppress or control emotions can lead to emotional fatigue, making it even harder to manage emotions over time. 

For athletes, this typically will manifest to a significant drop in performance.

Surface-Level Solution: 

Willpower often deals with the symptoms of emotional distress rather than the underlying causes. 

This can lead to temporary relief but doesn’t address the deeper issues that need resolution. For example, an athlete might push through fear or anxiety, but without addressing the root cause, these emotions can resurface at critical moments.

Increased Stress: 

Continuously exerting willpower to control feelings can increase stress levels, creating a cycle where managing emotions becomes progressively more difficult as stress accumulates. 

This added stress can negatively impact an athlete’s performance, leading to mistakes or injuries.

Suppressing Emotions: 

Suppressing emotions through sheer willpower can lead to a buildup of unresolved feelings, potentially causing more significant emotional outbursts in the future. 

For athletes, this might mean a sudden and unexpected breakdown during a crucial moment of competition or critical time in the season.

The Strength of Emotions in Sports

Research and psychological insights suggest that emotions are much more powerful than thoughts. 

In fact, emotions can be up to five times stronger than our cognitive processes. Here’s why:

Biological Basis: 

Emotions are deeply rooted in our biology…

They originate in the limbic system, a more primitive part of the brain, which operates faster and with more intensity than the more recently evolved prefrontal cortex, where rational thinking occurs. 

This means that feelings can dominate an athlete’s mental state, often overriding strategic thinking.

Survival Mechanism: 

Emotions have evolved as a survival mechanism… 

They alert us to dangers and opportunities in our environment much quicker than our rational thoughts can process. 

For athletes, this means feelings can provide immediate, gut-level reactions that are crucial in fast-paced, high-stakes situations.

Broad Experience: 

Emotions are not just thoughts; they involve physiological responses, behavioral impulses, and subjective feelings. 

This holistic nature makes them more powerful and harder to control with mere willpower. 

An athlete might experience a racing heart, sweaty palms, and heightened alertness—all components of an emotional response.

Learn Faster: 

Emotional experiences are often more memorable and impactful than thinking experiences. 

This is because the emotional brain (limbic system) is closely linked to the parts of the brain responsible for memory (the hippocampus). 

Athletes can remember the thrill of winning and the heartache of defeat vividly, which influences their future performance and decision-making.

Effective Strategies for Managing Emotions in Sports

Given the limitations of willpower and the strength of emotions, it’s clear that athletes need a different approach to managing their emotional experiences. Here are some strategies that can help:

Mindfulness: Instead of trying to suppress emotions… 

Mindfulness practices, such as meditation and deep breathing, can help athletes increase awareness of their emotions and reduce their intensity.

Emotional Intelligence: 

Developing emotional intelligence involves recognizing, understanding, and managing your own feelings as well as recognizing and influencing the emotions of others. 

For athletes, this can lead to better emotional management, improved performance, and more effective communication with coaches and teammates.

Healthy Outlets: 

Engage in activities that provide healthy outlets for emotions, such as physical exercise, creative expression, or maybe most powerful is changing your environment. 

These outlets can help process emotions in a constructive manner.

Cognitive-Behavioral Techniques: 

Cognitive-behavioral techniques can help reframe negative thoughts and beliefs that contribute to emotional distress. 

We have to learn to tell different stories!

By changing the way athletes think and tell certain stories about a situation, they can alter their emotional response, leading to better performance under pressure.


Practice self-compassion by treating yourself with kindness and understanding during emotional struggles. 

One of the main reasons my mentor will never let me go into “story mode” to stir up all the negative feelings from retelling the story over and over again!

This reduces the additional stress of self-criticism, helping athletes to bounce back from setbacks more effectively.

Manage Your Emotions For Success

Emotions are powerful forces that significantly influence an athlete’s thoughts, behaviors, and overall performance. 

Relying solely on willpower to manage these potent experiences is not only ineffective but can also be counterproductive. 

Understanding the strength of emotions and adopting healthier, more sustainable strategies for emotional regulation can lead to more consistent and peak performance. 

Embrace your feelings, and let them inform and enrich your athletic experience, rather than attempting to suppress them through sheer force of will.

Check out and subscribe to our podcast for more value on performance and mindset:


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *